Occupancy first, ADR second: revenue management for independents
Hotel ADR comes second to occupancy in the approach Rogier Ensel brings to The Revenue Playbook. The former group revenue director at Cycas and founder of RevGen explains how independent hotels can run revenue management like a board game. He covers the Booking.com Genius parity trap, starting forecasting small and the tactics smaller properties use to push margin without a brand behind them.
Rogier EnselOwnerAsk Rogier about this conversation
A short answer from what was said in this episode, with the exact words and the minute.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Occupancy leads, rate follows
occupancy tells you whether the value is right or wrong, and ADR is only the measurement you move up or down.
The parity trap is self-made
Genius and resold OTA discounts leak your rate across partners until a lower offer shows up against your own property.
Start forecasting small
fill in one day's expectation, compare it to reality a month later, and repeat until the gaps shrink.
Pricing is risk management
rooms carry the risk of going unsold, and unseen urgency is what forces the discounts that erode margin.
There is only one deciding the price, and that is your end client and your guest.
Transcript
Click a timecode to watch from that moment.
0:00Cold open: we do not decide the prices
1
Rogier EnselWe do not decide the prices. Never. There's only one deciding the price, and that's your end client and your guest.
0:25Welcome and Rogier's background
4
the Future of HospitalityHey, everyone. Today with Rokia Ensel, owner of Refgen, former group director of revenue management for Sikos. Worked with all the big brands like Hilton, Marriott, IAG, and now focused on independent properties as a revenue management consultant. So hi.
Rogier EnselGood afternoon. Great to be here. Thank you for the invitation. It's really good to be here.
the Future of HospitalityReally good to have you here. We will touch on on a few topics. First question, maybe you can introduce yourself even a little bit better than what I did. What did you do? Where did you where were you focused on? What do you like to do in terms of revenue management?
Rogier EnselThank you. Oh, well, in terms of history and where I come from, originally coming from operations, worked or started in in F and B, working in restaurants, working in hotels. I was general manager, for Dutch hotel chain, Sharma hotels. And afterwards, I made the jump to revenue management because I really enjoy playing the board game of revenue management, so to say. Started in Amsterdam, worked for a couple of hotel operators, before starting, my last journey in in in, Cyprus hospitality. As you mentioned, a lot of brands, managed there. A lot of hotels was responsible as group, director of revenue for roughly 45, 46 hotels, and ranging from, like, West Western Europe, in in in The Netherlands, in in Brussels, in in London, Germany, Scandinavia. So lots of different markets. And up until now where I started my own company in revenue management, but then for the unbranded properties, really independent properties. And really from the belief that I think the the smallest property, so roughly the the hotels ranging from 10 to, let's say, seventy, eighty, rooms, can benefit the most from experience or revenue management, channel management, distribution, etcetera.
2:34Why small properties benefit most from revenue management
16
the Future of HospitalityIt's like playing chess, but if you start for the first time, you can use a little bit of help.
Rogier EnselYeah. But that yeah. Yeah. Exactly that. And and and, and although there is a lot of knowledge sitting in, with owners, with the unbranded properties, it is always good to have some experience, what channels do you use, what tactics do you use, what strategies, do you apply, what to avoid. Never go to book an account genius, for example.
the Future of HospitalityBooking.com will be very happy with the statement.
Rogier EnselSorry. Say that again?
the Future of HospitalityI said booking.com will be very happy with the statement.
Rogier EnselOh, they know.
the Future of HospitalityNo. I think, especially when, I I found it a very nice energy, to to to bring it into board games, because everyone can play board games. I think the question here is, are the board games they play with the bigger bigger brands, is is it a different board game than they play with this with the small ones, or is it actually the same, but it's played differently?
Rogier EnselIt's a really good question. I think with playing a board game with the bigger brands, you have the instructions on paper. You know exactly what to do, what what you can't do, what you should do, what you should avoid, what is forbidden, where you got penalized for. Whilst in the unbranded world, it's like an experience every single time, even for myself. I mean, I'm I'm used I started in the unbranded world. I moved to chains where I always thought, oh, that's so boring because everything is already done, like, a number of times, which is true, but you have much more time for other elements and really focus on strategy instead of trying to connect channel x to channel y as the example. But the unbranded world is so much more fun because it feels really like an entrepreneur. I always struggle with the work, but you know what I mean. It it it is it is really that element that is so enjoyable, and, you really need to do it yourself.
the Future of HospitalityIs it then, because you have, of course, have a lot of experience when stepping in this unbranded world. So you have your backpack with knowledge, which I think it always makes a little bit easier to exploit, those never exploit grounds in this in this in this specific area. Can you imagine that it's gonna be pretty terrifying, for people if they don't have that that backpack and they they are in the unbranded world, which basically can be a world west because they are not really rules or not really set rules, that is that is pretty terrifying for them to step in this.
Rogier EnselYes. But at the same time, also very easy because you can just do what you want to do and work together with who you want to work together with. So, yes, it can be terrifying. At the same time, what you don't know, you don't know. Right? Oh, absolutely. You know booking a I mean, a lot of as as the example I use a lot of times, a lot of hotels are only connected to booking a common Expedia. Do you need more? Is the is the simple question. If you don't know other partners, you're not going to connect with, so it's not such a terrifying world. If you have the experience of the branded side and you want to and then this is my always my problem, because I know how it works in the branded world. You want to connect all those channels, for the independent hotels as well because you want them to benefit from the same exposure across multiple channels.
the Future of HospitalityBut can you answer the question you just said? Like, do they need it?
Rogier EnselDepends. Depends on market. Depends on country. Depends on source markets. Depends on hotel size. Hotels between 10 and, let's say or anything until 20, No. You can be fine with booking.com, and Expedia. If you are in a countryside, market, you need other, other channels as well. Are you in a city center? Fine. City center up until forty? Fine.
the Future of HospitalityThen it really depends on the the the demand generation in general. Right? Yeah. And how much you can cover from the total demand. But at least that's what I always say. You have a you have a certain balloon, and you need to capture a certain part of the balloon in order to to fill up your property. If the balloon is smaller, you should make sure that you can cover a bigger part of that balloon. I think that's also what you would what you tried to say here. But why do why do bigger hotels need it? Because they have a lot of exposure. They have a big name like Hilton Marriott. Why why would they need it?
Rogier EnselDifferent segments. I see I mean, there are, majority of hotels that I have worked with are more than roughly 120 rooms. So you speak about the 300 bedroom. You need multiple segments, multiple different areas of of you need the sales manager, to fill up a big portion of your of your of your inventory as well. So it's about what type of segments are coming into your hotel, what do we need to fill up, what how many rooms can we fill up with solely booking that common Expedia. It reaches a certain maximum Yeah. Across the month. So you need a lot more, channels, segments, to fill up a bigger hotel.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. Again, you need a bigger piece of the balloon in order to fill up the size of the property you have then.
Rogier EnselCorrect.
9:46Investor numbers versus family owned emotion
26
the Future of HospitalityAnd coming from from an investor side, is there a difference? Like working for a group of investors having properties or helping independent properties?
Rogier EnselYeah. I think there is a big difference where from an investor side, I think there is there is a lot of focus on numbers solely, where from a not investor, let's say, family owned business or it's more there are much more emotions coming into play. And I think those are two typical key differences, for the business.
the Future of HospitalityAnd and why is that, do you think?
Rogier EnselBecause if you have a family owned business or you have inherited it from your mother, your father, or whoever, or you started the the the company yourself, I think there is a lot of emotional aspects of why this is you are really attached to the property, and that makes it so much more emotional whilst an investor investing in a big property and does that for the fourth time. It's about the the return on investment, that they find much.
the Future of HospitalityIt's about the number on the paper at the end of the day.
Rogier EnselYeah. Whilst and this is the weird thing. The family owned business also needs to make money. Right? I mean, why why would you otherwise run that yourself? But there is much more emotional aspects to it. Plus, I think family owned business, you work yourself in that property, makes it much more emotional attached, whilst an investor, most of the times, sits in an office not really working in the property, having people working in the property there.
the Future of HospitalityOh, you you have this I'm not sure if it's a myth or it's actually the truth where I think it was an airline which didn't allow their, own employees to fly, with the airline itself because then they were were emotionally attached to the actually the service and the quality they deliver. And they just want to have people do it based on numbers. Yeah. And, again, I'm not sure if it's a myth, but it's I think it's closer to to the reality of investors, which, in my experience, sometimes just ask, oh, what why can the ADR not be 20 higher? Or why why should the maximum price not be 1,000 instead of 600? Well, with a Yeah. Family owned businesses like, oh, yeah. We ask now 130. I'm not really sure if that's really worth it. So maybe we
Rogier Enselshould other way around or the other way of the spectrum. Right? It should be $3,400.
the Future of HospitalityYep.
Rogier EnselBecause I invested so much in it, and it's worth that much. And that is that is also the emotional aspect.
the Future of HospitalityWhat what do you think has a better judgmental of the quality of the product?
Rogier EnselI I think it should be always a mixture because it can never be solely about the numbers. It can never be solely about emotions.
the Future of HospitalityAnd and how would you how would you rate it? Like, if you if you speak to to one of your, your clients and you have to do an exercise, hey. What's what's actually the value, the maximum value, or the minimum value of the property? How how would you do it?
Rogier EnselMhmm. Data. Solely data driven.
the Future of HospitalityAnd then
Rogier EnselThe data will tell you the data will tell you what what the potential can be, is, or will be. I don't I don't think there is one set of answer.
the Future of HospitalityWould you then use the data to draw guidelines and then, I mean, emotion will be involved anyway, especially when it's a family owned business, to to show them one thing that is based on data and then let their own thoughts be there? Because at the end of the day, they will they
Rogier Enselwill try it right. First, no. I would I would always ask first on their own opinion and their own because then you know where you need to work towards to, if that makes sense. And let's do the data exercise afterwards.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. Have you ever experienced that you need to to widen the gap, like, between minimum and and maximum? And that they had a opinion about that, and you actually think, oh, it maybe should be a
Rogier Ensellittle bit less. This is this is regardless of investor, regardless of family owned business because we have this in the investor world where people have a high opinion on no. No. No. We should not sell below a €100 or a 150. But similar to higher numbers or never never, by the way, a maximum number. But but that is there there is no difference between that because there are always people that have a certain knowledge, why they feel that Yeah. You should go left or right.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. No. True. I'm I'm just curious to see if there if there are differences in those kind of things because, it's like overvalue and undervaluing at one point. And and I think both of them are based on emotions very often. E even on the investor side, it sounds like it's also emotion based because they value themselves the product higher than it maybe is in the market they are in. Because at the end of the day, that's why I always tell to to customers, this room is never changing, unless you do a refurbishment, of course. But there are a lot of other factors which are actually putting the value on that room, which makes it harder to just This
Rogier Enselis always well, this is always the interesting topic. Right? What makes the room more expensive other than demand and supply? Right? Let's not go into that topic because that will be endless, but but just a simple 20 square meter bedroom.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. Tell me why is And
Rogier Enselwhy and why should 22 or 24 square meters suddenly be 50 or €100 more expensive?
the Future of HospitalityWhy do you think? Or shouldn't be?
Rogier EnselI don't I don't believe no. No. No. I don't believe it. I I believe in the small steps. I believe just run the occupancies first and rate comes after because most of the times, the majority and this is always how we determine room room type supplements. And no. No. No. It's €50 on top of the standard rate. No. No. 100. 150. And first, we need to realize and their data comes into play, we need to realize, oh, we are not selling this room or room category at all. Why is that? And it's the the most well, this is, I think, the the only reason is supplement pricing.
16:39Occupancy first, then rate: setting room supplements
13
the Future of HospitalityYeah. Because if if the other rooms are selling, there is apparently a demand.
Rogier EnselYeah.
the Future of HospitalityHowever, then there is a specific reason
Rogier EnselWhat is the right supplement then, for that room type?
the Future of HospitalityAnd and that Until we're starting low,
Rogier Enselachieve at least 80% occupancy in that room type, and then increase and increase and increase until the moment you see that number deriving from what you expect.
the Future of HospitalityWould you say because I'm I'm a bit triggered by by the fact that you use occupancy. Would you say there is a difference between what independent properties and investor or brand properties value more? Where are they more focused on? Is it occupancy, or is it ADR? And is there a difference?
Rogier EnselI don't think there is because both parties are dealing with banks, are dealing with with other parties that want to see return on investment. And return on investment starts at ADR level because everyone I mean, in essence, in every market, in every corner of the world, you should be able to run a 80% occupancy. So the differential of what, where profit will be higher or lower is because of ADR levels. So to answer the question, I don't think there is a difference where it comes to unbranded properties, family owned businesses versus investor side. Everyone will be focused on that ADR level.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. And but does then occupancy make the ADR or makes ADR the occupancy?
Rogier EnselWell, the and this is where opinions differ a lot.
the Future of HospitalityI know.
Rogier EnselBut I I well, I mean and and there's no right or wrong because when I say x, someone else will say, no. No. No. No. That's that's incorrect. But I I still think that you first focus on occupancy and making sure you showcase growth. You are selling whatever you are selling. And regardless if that is about hotel room or an airline ticket or you need I mean, if no one is traveling, what's the point of a certain rate level? If no one is staying in your hotel, what's the point of a certain rate? So it is always about occupants. Occupancy tells you if it's right or wrong, and ADR is then the measurement where you move up or down.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. I I I I think I share the same. I know that that the opinions differ a lot. I think if we go back to the chess game, you you can play chess a little different ways, and you can win in a little different ways as well. But but for me, it's it's very similar. Like, like, occupancy tells you if you actually if if if the value you put on your room is actually converting into an actual cell. Well and, of course, on its own, it doesn't say much. ADR on its own doesn't say anything because you can have a €400 ADR with one roof sold. You you can have 100% occupancy with a €10 ADR. I mean, it it doesn't say much. However, it
21:00Genius, mobile discounts, and the parity trap you build
20
Rogier Enselrevenue management game introduction is.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. It is. And then and then to the bigger brands, because you already said that bigger brands work with more restrictions in in words. Hey. You can do this. You cannot do this. You get a punishment for this. You can would you say that makes life a bit easier or the other way around? Like, it makes also life bit harder because sometimes I would like to go left, but I'm not allowed to go left.
Rogier EnselWell, the interesting part of this one is I mean, with in my time with Sykes, we did a lot of of, refurbishments also from an unbranded property to a branded property where and especially if unbranded properties utilize a lot of the tactical promotions, for example, from booking.com or from Expedia, the member aids, the genius, the promotion x, promotion y, promotion z. You cannot utilize that in the brand new world at all. Zero. Zero tolerance as well. I mean, Marriott will penalize you. Hilton will penalize you. Moving from unbranded to branded and expecting a better outcome in performance is sometimes not the reality and even where even the big brands are not able to bridge the gap for moving from unbranded to branded.
the Future of HospitalityAnd why is that?
Rogier EnselAnd that is how impactful well, that is how impactful booking.com production on Genius, sometimes is, or the production on, mobile discounts is. And we can hate it or like it, but that is sometimes where the bigger brands feel, no. No. You're you're we're doing a much better job without all this, which I highly stand for because I I truly would not advise anyone, joining these kinds of promotions because you create a very weird marketplace yourself with the parity issues. Well, because when you when you sell, I don't know, on Agoda with a 10% discount, Agoda will resell this to a partner of Agoda. And that partner of Agoda will resell this to booking.com, where you suddenly see in your screen, there's a partner offer for booking.com for your property, which is €20 lower.
the Future of HospitalityYep. I think this is a
Rogier Enselhuge create this, you create this yourself.
the Future of HospitalityAnd I think this is the biggest struggle where where people get very annoyed by by those platforms. And they and and and UC is a lot that they don't understand where it's actually coming from, which makes sense because it goes to a lot of different places before it ends up when you're played again. And if you don't know the infrastructure behind it, then it's really, really hard to figure out where things are actually coming from. But with why would people use, genius?
Rogier EnselWhy the end client would use Genius or why hoteliers
the Future of HospitalityThe hotels. Use? Because for the end client, I get it.
Rogier EnselIt does. It does. Well, it does what it promises to do. Where I feel and now I need to be careful. I feel that GMEI's program delivers more, where Expedia is more in the resell environment. I do think with booking.com, you are receiving a lot more volume, And you can enable or disable it with booking.com. You can, Yeah. Disable the the that they resell their, genius rates, for example, to their partners.
the Future of HospitalityYeah.
Rogier EnselBecause otherwise, you're just cannibalizing, whatever you already are doing. With Expedia, with Agoda, and with any other party, this is very different, and there the there it gets very funky, weird because it just the rates disappear and suddenly come back in most weirdest places.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. And and for for big brands, why why would what would be the the biggest benefit to brand your property?
Rogier EnselTo to sorry. Say again.
the Future of HospitalityNo. From unbranded to branded. What would be the biggest benefit?
Rogier EnselCommission, brand delivery in general, and all the pros that are attached using, I mean, you get so much awareness positively from becoming a Marriott, a Hilton, an Accord, what's whatever, type of brand. You get so much more loyal guests. And loyal guests, of course, on the long run spend much more, than the the single visit visitor from from booking a con, let's say, like that. So yeah.
the Future of HospitalityWould let let now we're gonna make a jump to another topic. But, is it easier to forecast when you're part of a brand than when you are unbranded?
Rogier EnselAre you saying this with a certain statement? Because I would not honestly, I would not know why it would be easier when you are branded unless you're targeted at the systems you're able to utilize. No. I think I think
the Future of HospitalityI think my question is more triggered by the fact that you say, hey. You might have more loyal guests. And I know that it's very hard to to to see when those guests are coming back and which specific area are they coming back. But having this pool of of more stabilized, a more stable platform than going up, down, up, down with all the cancellations we see, now and then on booking.com. Because I still believe that that the cancellation rate on booking.com is much higher than any other platform, which in that specific sense makes it more easy to do a prediction when you have more stable, reservations. So I think it's more coming from from that specific point of view. Maybe we can get get back to this question in general Yeah. Later. I I want forecasting in general. Just just a quick tip for everyone. How would you start? Where do you start with making a forecast? Because people tend to make a forecast based on a crystal ball, and they are like, hey. I have this this revenue now. Next year, I want to do plus 10%, and they call it a forecast.
28:35Where to start a forecast: budget and market
54
Rogier EnselYeah. Actually, it is. Starts yeah. Well, that is that is where the budget comes into play. No? I mean, it all it all starts with the budget and it's and and your budget process or your forecast process, depending on on on how much or how far you look in advance, We'll start with the with market analysis and market expectations and what is that expectation. Do we have a VAT increase in in The Netherlands again next year, or will the VAT be lowered? That's not real. But that all influences what what you are going to expect, in terms of rate values, what what what well, the war in in in in, in The Middle East is is also, impacting travel in general where groups are canceling much more. Maybe there is less group demand next year. So that is your starting point, where it comes to, where to start first, if that makes sense.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. I think the doing and the license in general, starting what what it is expected behavior is one thing. And then, of course, there are parts which are, I think, slightly less predictable. I think I always find it harder with groups, with group sales in general because sometime of course, you have repeatable groups. I mean, those
Rogier Enselare
the Future of Hospitalitypretty easy. But when do groups actually start to come in? Do they actually start to come in? And groups in general is more like a you you do you do a bid on a group because they request multiple, offers. But it's like a like a blindsided bit on no. You know, you don't know what anyone else, like, offered them. Of course, that that still depends a lot on the market, how what what your take on the market would be, how far they need to go with the offers. But there are a lot of there's a lot of flexible parts here.
Rogier EnselYeah. But but I I I think touching on groups, I think per market, you roughly know what you can expect in terms of rate values. I mean, if you're outside, I mean, take Amsterdam as the example. You know what you can expect rate wise around Schiphol area. You know what you can expect in Amsterdam city center if you want groups anyway. But, so from that angle, it's about the expectation of that market specific. And then does that match your expectation on your own rate, whether or not you want to accept or decline, the group request in general, if that makes sense.
the Future of HospitalityAnd and is it do you think it's easier for, for bigger properties, like, to to to forecast or for independent properties? Because there are there are
Rogier EnselThen then you mean the smaller properties or the bigger. Properties?
the Future of HospitalityYes. Yeah.
Rogier EnselNot so much the independent
the Future of HospitalityLet's say let's say between a 30 room or a 130.
Rogier EnselI think it's well, it is different. It is different forecasting because with a 150 bedroom property or 200 bedroom property, you have much more segments to forecast, where a 30 bedroom property solely relying on booking.com and Expedia. So it's literally transient business in general. But that same transient business in general, you apply for that bigger property as well. So that is equal forecasting. But then on top of that bigger property, you have the expected amount of groups. What are you going to expect in terms of groups? How many requests have you got, and what is the expectation on will it convert or won't it convert?
the Future of HospitalityFor for a bigger for the the the bigger properties, how would you start? Would you start with, like, the trenchant with, like, the more, in my eyes, more market focused? Or would you start with the groups, corporates,
Rogier Enseland and
the Future of Hospitalityall the others?
Rogier EnselYeah. Groups. Groups and well, I I I always used to forecast in three layers, which is then your your fixed blocks, like the crew type of of, of blocks that you have. You have your group's expectations, and you end up with your with your transient because a lot of a lot of a bigger part of your forecast is determined by the fact whether or not you have those blocks anyway in your in your hotel, and and it results as well in, oh, I have humongous amount of groups on on Saturday, the the, I don't know what, of September. I need to up my rate there. So your expectation on the transient side, when it comes to ADR on that specific day, will increase as well.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. You have to it's like this this game you have, like, a like a ball and you put in, like, the bigger balls first and the smaller ones, and then you fill it up with sand. And, basically, sand is like the the trench in business. And some days you need more, some days you need less, and that will determine the the ADR you set. Right?
Rogier EnselBut you can turn that around as well. No? I mean, in the end, if the expectation on transient is that strong, do you want groups?
the Future of HospitalityBut would you but but but you first said that you want to do the the the groups and and stuff and then
Rogier EnselBecause you contract them in in much more in advance. Right? But it and this is and this is about where do you start when do you start forecasting? Are we forecasting in, from today until three months in advance, or am I forecasting for next year? There's a big difference because looking into next year, you only have your events that you can rely on. Other trends are not visible just yet, Only the the the big. So for those dates, you know, I don't want groups or I only want high paying groups.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. And indeed. And, for for the smaller ones, but it's more focused on trends. It's more focused on on a on a market trend in general. Yeah. Do you feel that, that a lot of smaller properties actually do forecasting? No. And what do what do they do then? Do they or do but maybe they don't do anything.
Rogier EnselThe ones I have seen, I've not come across a lot of properties unless it is, like, a hotel group of smaller hotels. They do expect they do expect a forecast, but the independent family owned businesses or self owned businesses often do not forecast at all.
the Future of HospitalityBut why do the smaller groups forecast?
Rogier EnselBecause they want to have an expectation on the future.
the Future of HospitalityBut who wants to have the expectation?
Rogier EnselWell, someone within the company wants to have an expectation.
the Future of HospitalityIs it then is it then very often the owner
Rogier Enselor one
the Future of Hospitalityof the investors maybe?
Rogier EnselI think I think and and I and I I think it's multilayered. I think finance wants to know the expectation as well. What what what is the expectation on on on the future, and are we able to to pay the costs, pay the rent, pay whatever we need to pay? And a CEO wants to see that as well, but wants to most of the times, wants to see it just, where you say that.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. More broader
Rogier EnselYeah.
the Future of HospitalityAcross the whole group.
Rogier EnselNo. I'm looking forward. You need to cut this. That's fine. Consolidated. Thank you. Ah. He wants to see the consolidated view, instead of properties individually, I think.
the Future of HospitalityAnd but then if I maybe this conclusion is very wrong. But, would you then say that the properties which are part of a structure, and a structure, I mean, having actually set different departments, will most likely work with a forecast where the family owned businesses, where everyone does everything, basically are going with the flow.
Rogier EnselYeah. Got
the Future of Hospitalityit. And would you then say they need a forecast?
Rogier EnselThey should need a forecast.
the Future of HospitalityWhy?
Rogier EnselAnd and and this is maybe my con. I I don't know. But I would want to know what the future will bring and how my costs then would be spread or it makes it makes a lot of stuff so much easier to plan or schedule your cleaning and how much cleaning do we need. What what will be the end result. But at the same time, you're able when I forecast now for that same two months, you're still able to take a steer on the potential end result, where if I, tomorrow, look back on past months, that is something I can't change. And let's
the Future of HospitalityDo they actually look back?
Rogier EnselI don't know. Should they look back? I do think.
the Future of HospitalityI think evaluation
Rogier EnselEveryone everyone regardless if we speak about hospitality or your own behavior, everyone should look back and learn from what happened. So, yes, hotels should not on a daily base and a for a full day, but a moment of thirty minutes or an hour, look at their results and plan what to improve for next time.
the Future of HospitalityThen maybe this is a bit of a tricky question then, But do you think that everyone has the tools and the skill sets in their backpack in order to actually look back and take a learning from it?
Rogier EnselNo. Because I think No. As in no as in have everything in their backpack. No. Because you started once being an entrepreneur and learning as you go. Right? I mean, I've I've done a lot in my life, but, made the jump in November last year being entrepreneur and starting this company, and every day learning again, like, we should tackle this differently next time. So and every entrepreneur will feel the same.
the Future of HospitalityEveryone has to know
Rogier Enselyou will never have that experience or that backpack filled with everything you need, but that's the joy as well.
the Future of HospitalityI mean, that's the that that that is the right. But, like, for for my feeling, making a forecast gives you the ability to actually optimize what's gonna happen in the future. And, therefore, I think it's really strong if people can actually do it. However, I also have the feeling that a lot of people, they might be able to do it, but they don't know how to act on it. So they might see something happening in the future, but they don't really know how to act on it. And if I look into, because once we we did the studies about how many people in Amsterdam do actually actively change their prices. And then what you see is that, of course, all the bigger brands, they're actively doing the pricing. And I mean, actively is not only, like, a month before arrival. It's also a bit further in the future. However, what you see a lot is that people only start to take action two weeks before arrival because then they actually see the the pattern where it says Then
Rogier Enselthe panic starts starts to kick in.
the Future of HospitalityAnd they are really focused on that. And I think you said it in the earlier stage. What you don't know, you don't know. And I think this this procedure of what you don't know, you don't know really applies, when a market is slightly changing. So if you would know, you maybe start worrying, but at the end of the day, everything was still gonna be fine. However, now all markets are changing slightly. And I had a conversation lately where, where the lady said to me as well, like, we are not really used to to big impactful changes in our market because there was a growth year over year of a few percentages every time. However, if you speak to someone who's doing revenue management in Turkey, they have inflation rates going up, going down. Like, the market's constantly changing, and they are really there to adapt on what's actually happening. Where here, we didn't really have to adapt. We're just, like, step by step growing. And what I feel now that people now starts to get a little bit worried because the results are not coming in automatically anymore, what they were expecting before, which might be a very big shift in the fact if they're gonna start forecasting because now there's actually something to optimize, to need to optimize in order to bring the same results as the years before, where the years before, it was like it's like a it was like a stare. Like, oh, you you just walk upwards.
Rogier EnselYeah. But it it it was I mean, post COVID, it was only improving, improving, improving. Right? Yeah. Only because of the VAT uplift, suddenly, The Netherlands also reaches a certain ceiling.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. If you look now at London, for example, I think London, also suffers from from the Middle East.
Rogier EnselYeah.
the Future of HospitalityEspecially the the more high value properties, they had a lot of Middle East guests, and now they start to to suffer a bit. Or at least the results are not coming in that easy as the years before, where now actually people have a trigger to search for a way to optimize instead of, oh, it will be fine at the end of the day. So why should I look already in the future? Because, it's proven year over year that the results will come anyway. And I think this is one of the first years. And maybe you saw it last year in q one a little bit. But this year, I think you you this is the first time we actually saw that results are not coming that easy. And, of course, it's also because of the VAT and the the net value has been decreased because we pay more tax. But it's really interesting to see that shift. And and when making that shift, especially for the for the properties you work with, what would you advise to them, in a way of forecasting? Where where should they start? Like, where where can they start?
45:39Just start forecasting: small steps that compound
4
Rogier EnselDo not perceive it well. I think a lot of people make forecasting as well very big as the big rock that they need to get over, and and and they make it so big for themselves where it's just just start. Just look at days and start where filling in your expectation of a certain day. And if you truly have no clue, look at the rates that you're selling for. So how would that convert into what ADR? And fill it in. Do it once. Look back on it, on what you filled in a month ago versus the reality. See where it went wrong. Were you too optimistic in the rates? Were you too optimistic in the occupancy? And do it again and do it again. Because even I mean, I've done a million forecasts in my life. Every property we start with is like a new forecast, a new we have also no clue. We have the experience of doing it, but not the experience of the actual property.
the Future of HospitalitySo So also learn learning is on the right. Right? And and and we discussed this in in another call earlier where actually learning along the way, at one point, you get more information than what you had before. And when you have more information, you can basically review what you actually did. Yeah. And along the line, we'll get better and better. And and then the the I think the big question always rises, what is a good forecast? Because, people sometimes think that a forecast should be within one percent of the end result, three months before arrival, or half a year before arrival. I mean, if you know someone who can do that, then please let me know. Would would be
Rogier EnselEvery everyone always projects that in their company, we all always have it right. Always within the within the five the 5% is always the holy ground. Right?
the Future of HospitalityYeah. I think it's really hard to be to be there, especially in And and maybe over the past years, it was just a little bit easier when we saw, like, year over year slight growth. But now we're going into more ongoing ground. I think I think it's getting a little bit harder to actually project this forecast because no one really knows what our market is doing. And I think a lot of properties, they don't have all the data of a market, and they they sometimes rely on what someone called to me an echo chamber. People are saying that it's gonna be, it's amazing at the company. Like, the market is saying, are we doing so well? Actually, maybe they don't even do that well, but they they just like, to the outside world, they always up with 10%, where you get at one point this feeling of like, you get this good oh, oh, shit. I I should do better. Where it's not the truth. It's just like the myths which are around you and and just basically gaslighting you at one point. And, into the into this this new world where I think for some people, it's a new world, where it's not really common to do forecasting and also to make a budget. Because my pro biggest problem with a budget is always you make a budget and then someone says based on a forecast, and then someone says, no. It should be 10% higher. It's like, yeah. But why why did it do a forecast?
49:08Budget versus forecast and the 10 percent ask
41
Rogier EnselThe point of a budget?
the Future of HospitalityYeah. No. And that's that's also and may and it's I think a budget is very much related to a forecast in a sense. But why should people what's the difference for you between the budget and the forecast?
Rogier EnselIt depends on who you ask, I think.
the Future of HospitalityFrom your interest?
Rogier EnselInvestor. Well, I mean, for me, a budget and a forecast is is not so much different because the budget is just a very long term forecast.
the Future of HospitalityYep.
Rogier EnselI mean and and in all honesty, I mean and also depending on who you ask because a lot of a lot of hotels forecast eighteen months in advance. Right? So they already make half the budget
the Future of HospitalityYeah.
Rogier EnselAlready in essence. Back to your question.
the Future of HospitalityFrom an investor point of view, is there a difference between a budget and a forecast?
Rogier EnselIt's a it yeah. The budget should be an ambitious goal, where in my eyes or in the eyes of a of a of a revenue manager, interesting on your answer, by the way, then as well, it should be a a truly long term forecast. And, of course, ambitious, but ambitious with within reach. Not ambitious. Let's increase your goal with 10%.
the Future of HospitalitySo I think that this is what what I struggle always with when making budgets. And because when you make a budget and you present the budget, then someone says it should be 10% higher. Just find a way to increase it with 10%. I mean, you can also ask me to increase it with 200%. It's also fine because I'm just gonna make it up.
Rogier EnselYeah.
the Future of HospitalityAnd you're like, oh, but maybe I can put a little bit here. Maybe I could put a little bit here. And at the end of the day, to be fair, like, if you don't reach your budget and at the beginning of your year of the year, you did already know that you're not gonna reach the budget because you made your forecast. You had a certain expectation of what the market will look like, but someone told you it should be 30% higher, which surprises me almost a lot. Yeah. Because what I always feel is that and and this may be my point of view based on the budget because if you make a budget, it's not only across what's coming in. Because you also make a budget, your projected budget of what's the spend I gonna have on a lot of other things. And then my Correct. My question here is then in general to everyone, maybe they can maybe they can put a comment under it. If you increases your budget because that's what you wanted, but we don't think it's feasible and we have to increase everything because you say it should be 10% higher, are your cost by starting point also 10% higher than if it's related to each other? Like, what's what's driving the budget? Is driving the budget the cost you're gonna you have?
Rogier EnselThe rent.
the Future of HospitalityAnd and The
Rogier Enselrental cost in in it often. I mean, look around and look into, hotel operations. Depending on what star level, what ambition you have for for your property, but your cleaning costs will always be in a certain range. Right?
the Future of HospitalityYep.
Rogier EnselYour your expenses, if you want to do fresh flowers every day, it will increase. If you don't do fresh flowers every day, it will be the so a lot of stuff you can precisely forecast, or whether or not your hotel will be profitable depending a lot on on rental cost because that is sometimes that dramatic that a hotel property will never make money.
the Future of HospitalityYep. Is that is is that also a difference between, working for investor company and, with independent owned properties, which I
Rogier EnselI Independent. I I think independent owned properties are often much more realistic when it comes to rental cost. And maybe some people will now say, oh, well, that's not true. But the ones that I've seen are more realistic within the investor world. I think they're they're that that is insane sometimes.
the Future of HospitalityAnd, like, in an investor world, but maybe it can be an assumption. I don't know. Is it that they also rent a lot, or is it that they also buy the properties?
Rogier EnselSay that again?
the Future of HospitalityDo they actually buy the properties and then start operating the hotel? Or, is it like renting the property and then
Rogier EnselMixture. Sometimes you own the building. Sometimes someone else owns the building.
the Future of HospitalityBecause that makes a big difference on, on on your budget. Yeah. Of course. Because the potential, and and the of course, really depends how much you pay, of course. I mean, it depends on a lot of different factors, but, the potential is gonna be completely different. And therefore, also, like, the budgeting is gonna be completely different. But then let let let's move into another topic. And and I'm very interested in this one because you worked what I saw in a lot of for a lot of different properties in a lot of different cities. Do you have a city where you're like, not not only forecasting wise, but also, just revenue management wise, is the hardest city to work in?
Rogier EnselThe hardest city to work.
the Future of HospitalityOr the easiest? We can do both.
Rogier EnselThe hardest? I think in the middle of nowhere in Germany, but Piedmont was the hardest because there is literally there's nothing there. They're literally booking 50 people are booking on booking.com, the property in in three months. So and it's hard because you really need to, to invest in where where for a lot of hotels and a lot of key cities, it's very easy to to to get hotel guests in because people book through booking.com and Expedia and your own website. In certain areas, you just need to find people or really be specific or people are booking you because of a unique building or a unique product that you have. But if you are not the destination, and the destination itself is not selling itself, that that is that is hard.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. And and in terms of of competitive landscape, like, which which are there markets which are more for example, Berlin or Copenhagen or Amsterdam, which are much more competitive to each other? Like, the competitiveness is is much higher. People are attempting to be much more aggressive on pricing. Or does it that's
Rogier Enselnot really London is is quite competitive. London, Amsterdam, Berlin as well. Berlin.
the Future of HospitalityOr it's just the correct Zurich
Rogier Enselis a is a real insane expensive market.
the Future of HospitalityYeah.
Rogier EnselI find that one really, really intrigued about it. Yeah.
the Future of HospitalityIs it then in general that that the, like, the bigger cities is the case or not not for all of them? Or depends how many hotels there are?
Rogier EnselYeah. Depends on supply. Yeah. The more supply there is yeah.
the Future of HospitalityI mean, I mean, I
Rogier EnselI the more mini markets you you create. Right? Because in the end, everyone looks at London as a market, but London is not a market at itself. It has the South Bank, the North Bank, the left side of the center, the right side. I
the Future of Hospitalitymean, I I find London, like, very crazy as a market, especially now especially nowadays because it it relies on so many different, things, even more than than, for example, Amsterdam, I think. Because, I think with London, especially with the with the whole aspect maybe it's now even more with the whole ex aspect of, like, Brexit, of course, you had, but now with the whole Middle East situation where I think London might be one of the biggest cities relying on Middle East traffic. Paris? Yeah. Could could also be, but I I I think they're much more relying on the Middle East traffic than, for example, Amsterdam.
Rogier EnselOh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Definitely. But that is that is also why I don't see and we might see that in in in future because the moment you say it, it will happen, of course. But that's why I don't see in Amsterdam that much impact from the Middle East conflict.
59:18Building a hotel in Copenhagen from scratch
58
the Future of HospitalityYeah. Then then I have always lost
Rogier EnselOnly the group side only the group side is unreliable.
the Future of HospitalityYeah.
Rogier EnselBut transient wise, your your key source markets are around you anyway. It's Germany. It's Belgium. It's it's it's The UK. So they keep traveling.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. Maybe it's only for, like, the five star properties high end that it might be a little bit of impact.
Rogier EnselCould be.
the Future of HospitalityBecause the ability ability to spend bigger amounts of of money, I think, is a little bit ease. Like, what we see is a little bit easier for, for people from The Middle East. Not for everyone, of course, but for some. Then I I've always one one question. If we together are gonna start a hotel, first of all, where are we gonna put it? How many rooms? And how do we build a strategy? So where do we put our hotel?
Rogier EnselWhere do we put our Copenhagen?
the Future of HospitalityOkay. How many rooms?
Rogier Ensel95.
the Future of HospitalityAnd do we do
Rogier EnselDon't ask me why.
the Future of HospitalityDo we do, events, or do we have a wellness, or do we have a restaurant? Or
Rogier EnselNo restaurant. You get in. You have breakfast. Yes. But then exit the door. I would if if I would sorry?
the Future of HospitalitySelf check-in?
Rogier EnselNo. Reception. No. I'm I'm I'm too old school. I like too emotional, maybe. No. I like the I like the personal check-in.
the Future of HospitalityK. From a business point of view?
Rogier EnselYou would go for self check-in. K.
the Future of HospitalityAnd where do we start? Like, how do we build our pricing strategy?
Rogier EnselDepending on where we are.
the Future of HospitalityIn Copenhagen?
Rogier EnselDepending on yeah. But, I mean, Copenhagen is big as well.
the Future of HospitalityIn the city center.
Rogier EnselIn the city center. What? What were you holding?
the Future of HospitalitySo I'm Parker, we are you we are price polite of. Of a tip sign. Alright. Let let me ask something else in between. Would it be branded or unbranded?
Rogier EnselUnbranded.
the Future of HospitalityOkay. Are we gonna do a forecast for the and the budget?
Rogier EnselYes. We do.
the Future of HospitalityOkay. And how are we gonna start with the budget? Do we look at our costs first? Do we look at what's
Rogier EnselTop line first.
the Future of HospitalityOkay. So, where do we start?
Rogier EnselWe start with the market analysis and where the the ADR levels will be sitting. Based on that, we we produce an ADR.
the Future of HospitalityK.
Rogier EnselBased on that ADR, we are deciding what kind of segments we need and what we are going to get in. Mhmm. With the 95 rooms, I would opt into some groups. No weird tours or whatsoever, but just a couple of smaller high end tools.
the Future of HospitalityWould we go for proper contracts?
Rogier EnselYes. Always. But no Stavix.
the Future of HospitalityYep.
Rogier EnselI would always go for the Lambix.
the Future of HospitalityYep. So discount on bar.
Rogier EnselYeah. And that can be aggressive. Right? Yeah. Yeah.
the Future of HospitalityThat can
Rogier Enselbe I mean, 15 plus percentage discount. It should be. K. As well because our nonrefundable discount will be 15%.
the Future of HospitalityYep. And then, okay. We have this. But where do we get the data from the market from? Do we use, like SDR? Like SDR?
Rogier EnselYep. SDR as as great market reports. And, of course, there are other data banks that can produce, but I have always liked and enjoyed the the STR market reports because they they give quite a good look into the future.
the Future of HospitalityYep. So so I I think now we we are pretty far in I what I what me interest a lot is, like, we know what we're gonna sell, and we know what kind of property we have. And I think that's very important. Knowing, hey. What kind of property are you actually in order to to build this strategy? Because we already said, okay. We will be unbranded 95, some groups. We definitely go for corporates, because we need this 95 rooms. We can build a base from it. So I think I think that's one of the one of the steps for a lot of people. Get to know what what do you have, what do you need, and how to execute. And what do you have? I think for and here's the emotional part coming in for for my feeling. Because a lot of people are tempting to what do we have to to, like, downgrade it or upgrade it. So I think for sometimes for them, it's really difficult to actually say what do we actually offer, and what do I need to bring that offer to to the table. And and therefore, this is also this question because I'm really curious on how where do you actually start? Where can people actually start? What what kind of learning can they get from you and me putting a fixural property in Copenhagen? Because it it shows step by step where we actually will start in in this journey, which is for me really interesting. I think for a lot of people is really interesting because, there are not massive things. It's starting with those little little building blocks, but put them together. Like, make one big piece of it in order to, like, step up your game.
Rogier EnselAs long and and I and I think this this goes for revenue managers, for owners, investors, because there is a misperception in this is that we do not decide the prices. Never. There's only one deciding the price, and that's your end client and your guest.
the Future of HospitalityYeah.
Rogier EnselAnd that is really often and I and I see this in the investor world. I see this in in independent world that we are very tempted to decide what the price should be. But the only one deciding that is your guest.
the Future of HospitalityYeah. And and and here's also about how do you react to this. Because I I think I I once said I'm not sure if it was an approved customer, that you can better react quick than than project wrong. And and I think this is what you see sometimes that they project, oh, we should do this, this, and this. However, if all the signals are on red and you cannot make up your projection, you should act on what you see. And and here we come again to the point, hey. We have a certain takeaway from a certain point and with this information. However, along the way, we get more information. Please take that information into consideration of revisiting your strategy because the strategy will never be 100% accurate from the start.
Rogier EnselAnd never be 100% right. And it doesn't need to be a 100% right Because the strategy is never 100% fixed and unchangeable because it will change.
the Future of HospitalityI I think that the it's again, and we started this with with with this as well. Like, if you play chess, you have a certain strategy in mind. However, you have to react how your opponents what your what what kind of moves your opponent does. And in this specific case, you have I think here is like a three layer playing chess. You have a certain challenge you have in place, so that's the the actual actions you want to put out. Then you have a market reacting, so you have to adapt to it. Because if you don't do it up to it, then your end client, they will make another decision than booking with you, which at the end of the day still decides your price. But I think the the biggest thing in Dunkirk referral, just just start somewhere. Start somewhere, little steps, and then, like, building those little blocks will turn into a bigger block. And at the end of the day
Rogier EnselAnd that's why and that's why looking back on the results booked, analyze, and improve or or set, like, goals for yourself is as important as we touched on, halfway this one as well. Because I truly I truly believe in analyzing the data. Let data speak, and let data tell you what you need to adjust, alter, and and fine tune.
the Future of HospitalityYep. No. Definitely agree. And, we should never close our eyes for what data says, but we also should never 100% close our own eyes about or what we what we experience.
Rogier EnselIt's about the interpretation of the data.
the Future of HospitalityYeah.
Rogier EnselI mean, the data the data is what the data is. I mean, an ADR, you you can't change. But the interpretation and the story around why the ADR is the ADR, that is why, a certain result is viewed, bad, or indifferent.
the Future of HospitalityAnd is it also where you come in? As like as as the because you started to work in, for for
Rogier Ensela reason. Yeah. Oh, 100%. I mean, for for me, it's about I I one, I truly believe that the the the smaller hotelier, is able to push their profit margin much more than what they do today by applying certain tactics and strategies around what what what I have learned over my time in in the branded world, certain channels to utilize, certain rules of play of what we said already, and I'm not going to repeat that. Otherwise, I'm in trouble now. But do not do that. Applying these types of tactics, plus have have a BI to analyze your data, look at the data, and tell a story around the data. That makes you learn from the results, and that gives you provides you pillars to work for yourself in the future and to do things slightly different.
71:14We do not decide the price, the guest does
11
the Future of HospitalityYeah. It's drawing your own map. Right? You start with start with a few highways first, and then you're gonna draw the other bits and pieces around, but learn from it.
Rogier EnselAnd there's not and there's not one tactic or strategy that has a serve it all, way. Right? I mean, there's not one percentage nonrefundable discount you should apply, in all markets
the Future of HospitalityNo.
Rogier EnselAs an example.
the Future of HospitalityBut then, I mean, this would be boring as well. Right?
Rogier EnselTrue. And it's and and this is why the data that comes in, how much nonrefundables do you produce on a monthly base? And analyzing that data will tell you the answer. Is this sufficient or should we change?
the Future of HospitalityYeah. Do you have anything I missed? Or you maybe have a question for me. Could also be.
Rogier EnselThat's a good one. What would your what would your key price strategy be?
the Future of HospitalityWhat Only based
Rogier Enselon pillars. What three pillars should we all utilize in developing our strategy?
the Future of HospitalityI think for me, it always starts with the fact how's like, the things I get in, like, the the reservations I get in, how stable is the things I'm building on? Like, because sometimes you see that it's very fragile, and you start to build a house without any foundation. And especially when we, for example, go back to to the Copenhagen example, you need a certain, like, fixed, foundation to build things on. And the the bigger the foundation is, the e the more stable your pricing would be at the end of the day. Because we see it very often that it's that it's super it's super wavy. It goes up. It goes down because a lot of reservations come in. They fall out. And, also, here, it starts with, hey. What do I actually offer, and how can I get how can I stabilize my, my bookings there? Because if you have more stable bookings, you you don't got by surprise at the end of the day. Because for me, revenue management is a lot about how much risk am I willing to take in order to maximize my profit. Because at least it is all about risk. You can put a a a room for, like, €600, but there is a risk of not selling it. Mhmm. And the more urgency you have at one point, the less risk you are willing to take. And therefore, you drop your prices. So if we if you can find a builder strategy around, hey. How can I how can I make sure that not cut by surprise? So how can I make sure that I don't fall in this trap of, like, unseeing urgency of selling rooms already helps you a lot? Mhmm. And then it's all about what do we offer? What do we offer and to who can I offer this? And this is really about distribution. Like, okay. What what what kind of hotel do I have? What kind of gas do actually fit perfectly in my property? And what's the actual price I can charge towards this specific market? And how I'm gonna reach that market? And I I think those things will also contribute to the fact that you get much more stable bookings in. Because if you target the wrong market, it will be super fragile. And and and I'm very much aware that for some markets, it's really fragmented in a lot of small bits and pieces. Because if I look at bigger properties, it's like playing Tetris. I always said this. It's like playing Tetris. You have a block here. You have a block here, and you try to fit in everything. However, every block has a certain value. And with those little blocks, you're trying to create
73:50Revenue management as risk management
12
Rogier EnselA forecast.
the Future of HospitalityA forecast and a stacked value as well. Yeah. Where with smaller properties, you don't have to play Tetris. Correct. Because the amount
Rogier EnselWell, that's not that's not completely true. When you speak about a six bedroom hotel in the middle of Amsterdam, you paid Tetris as well because you will always have that orphan gap somewhere in between when you have a minimum length of
the Future of HospitalityYeah. Of course. But then it's more, like, on the room level and not not really on the segment level. Yeah. And I I think being aware of what you can offer and what you act what and what do you actually offer now? Because what you can offer, what do you offer can be differentiated a lot. And if all those like, if this is realigned, it will stabilizes your strategy in general. And I think that's really a thing. You cannot stabilize your pricing, when everything before is not aligned to each other. Because we can expect that we do, we change the price here, we change it there, but it's really reactive on a lot of things. The more you can stabilize, the less reactive you have to be because there is less urgency to sell rooms. And this is really the thing. And is revenue management a guessing game? Not really. It's guessing within with all the information you have, of course, because it's never a 100% the truth.
Rogier EnselBased on trends. Right?
the Future of HospitalityYeah. It's but it's not it's gonna be never a 100% the truth because it it can always change. It's like a stock market. You can have a certain prediction, but it can always change. And and then it's how do you act on it? How do you react on it? But at the end of the day, it's really a game about how much willingness to take risk do I have in order to achieve a higher revenue. And the more information you have, the quicker you can respond, the less less the risk will be. And I think that's really the thing for me. Focus on on those things to to align a little bit better on on the general level.
Rogier EnselMhmm. Was that pillar one? I'm kidding.
the Future of HospitalityWe we can maybe you should write a book.
Rogier EnselYes. I think you'd be a good book writer.
the Future of HospitalityNo. I don't think so. I'm I'm very dyslexic. So, let's let's skip that part. Maybe with maybe with AI
Rogier EnselWe talk outside.
the Future of HospitalityThat's that's fine. Maybe with AI nowadays. Perfect. But I think I think we covered a lot. And that is one last thing I want to say, and that's thank you. Thank you for being here. Thank you for sharing, and, thank you for speaking with me.
Read the article about this episode →



















